The Mega Mets Group-Think Top 50 Prospect List

Carson Benge, Photo by Kylie Richelle

From MLB.com to Baseball America to prospect huggers like Ernest Dove, there are quite a few Mets Prospect lists out there.  

What if combined those lists into one?  That was an idea that long time Blog reader and Mets Fan Bill Metsiac came up with.  I first did a combined list back in 2020 for Mack's Mets.

Today, I am taking 11 of the Top Mets Prospects lists, gave 50 points to the number one prospect and 1 point to the number 50 prospect.  I then added all the numbers together.

Some lists were complied when Brandon Sproat and Jett Williams were still on the team.  I removed them from my calculations to solve that.  

Another wrinkle was that MLB.com took Nolan McLean off the list just as the season began.  I also removed him from this calculation but even with MLB.com taking him off, he still would have been the #4 prospect on the combined list.  

All the different 11 lists are below.

But first, here is the combined list arranged by Rank, Player, Points, # of Lists:

#1, Carson Benge, 540, 11; #2, Jonah Tong, 530, 11; #3, A.J. Ewing, 519, 11; #4, Jacob Reimer, 493, 11; #5, Ryan Clifford, 481, 11; 

#6, Jack Wenninger, 474, 11; #7, Elian Peña, 469, 11; #8, Will Watson, 447, 11; #9, Jonathan Santucci, 443, 11; #10, Mitch Voit, 438, 11; 

#11, Zach Thornton, 425, 11; #12, Chris Suero, 420, 11; #13, Nick Morabito, 362, 10; #14, Dylan Ross, 336, 10; #15, Ryan Lambert, 325, 10; 

#16, Eli Serrano III, 320, 9; #17, Randy Guzman, 303, 10; #18, R.J. Gordon, 283, 9; #19, Boston Baro, 282, 9; #20, Antonio Jimenez, 250, 8; 

#21, Daiverson Gutierrez, 249, 9; #22, Wandy Asigen, 230, 6; #23, Marco Vargas, 212, 7; #24, Peter Kussow, 201, 8; #25, Yovanny Rodriguez, 193, 7; 

#26, Jonathan Pintaro, 192, 7; #27, Edward Lantigua, 192, 7; #28, Camden Lohman, 164, 7; #29, Daviel Hurtado, 125, 5; #30, Trey Snyder, 115, 5; 

#31, Cam Tilly, 98, 5; #32, Ben Simon, 94, 4; #33, Saul Garcia, 89, 5; #34, Jeremy Rodriguez, 70, 3; #35, Brendan Girton, 68, 4; 

#36, Colin Houck, 54, 3; #37, Nathan Hall, 54, 3; #38, Felipe De La Cruz, 53, 3; #39, Jose Chirinos, 47, 3; #40, Ronald Hernandez, 43, 3; 

#41, Cleiner Ramirez, 42, 3; #42, Joel Diaz, 38, 2; #43, Douglas Orellana, 38, 3; #44, Noah Hall, 37, 1; Yonatan Henriquez, 35, 3; #45, Yonatan Henriquez, 35, 3; 

#46, Brett Banks, 33, 1; #47, Peyton Prescott, 28, 2; #48, Justin Hagenman, 28, 1; #49, Yordan Rodriguez, 28, 2; #50, Hoss Brewer, 26, 1; 

    

Now Here's the 11 Lists that make up the composite list:

MLB.com:

1: Carson Benge; 2: Jonah Tong; 3: A.J. Ewing; 4: Ryan Clifford; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: Jack Wenninger; 7: Mitch Voit; 8: Elian Peña; 9: Jonathan Santucci; 10: Will Watson; 11: Wandy Asigen; 12:Nick Morabito; 13: Eli Serrano III; 14: Zach Thornton; 15: Chris Suero; 16: Antonio Jimenez; 17: Ryan Lambert; 18: Dylan Ross; 19: R.J. Gordon; 20: Marco Vargas; 21: Jonathan Pintaro; 22: Peter Kussow; 23: Boston Baro; 24: Randy Guzman; 25: Daiverson Gutierrez; 26: Camden Lohman; 27 Nathan Hall; 28: Cam Tilly; 29: Brendan Girton; 30: Camden Lohan.

 

Baseball America:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Ryan Clifford; 6: Jacob Reimer; 7: Jack Wenninger; 8: Jonathan Santucci; 9: Mitch Voit; 10: Elian Peña; 11: Nick Morabito; 12: Chris Suero; 13: Zach Thornton; 14: Will Watson; 15: Eli Serrano III; 16: Wandy Asigen; 17: Marco Vargas; 18: Boston Baro; 19: Antonio Jimenez; 20: Randy Guzman; 21: Jonathan Pintaro; 22: R.J. Gordon; 23: Daiverson Gutierrez; 24: Trey Snyder; 25: Dylan Ross; 26: Jeremy Rodriguez; 27: Peter Kussow; 28: Cam Tilly; 29: Ryan Lambert; 30: Camden Lohman; 31: Edward Lantigua; 32: Jace Hampson; 33:Brendan Girton; 34: Calvin Ziegler; 35: Colin Houck; 36: Yovanny Rodriguez; 37: Peyton Prescott:; 38: Anthony Frobose; 39: Josmir Reyes; 40: Saul Garcia;

 

Amazing Avenue:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: Ryan Clifford; 7:Will Watson; 8: Jack Wenninger; 9: Mitch Voit; 10: Jonathan Santucci; 11: Elian Peña; 12: Zach Thornton; 13: Nick Morabito; 14: R.J. Gordon; 15: Chris Suero; 16: Dylan Ross; 17: Ryan Lambert; 18: Antonio Jimenez; 19: Edward Lantigua; 20: Eli Serrano III; 21: Randy Guzman; 22: Daiverson Gutierrez; 23: Boston Baro; 24: Marco Vargas; 25:Peter Kussow;

Baseball Prospectus:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong: 48; 4: A.J. Ewing: 47; 6: Jacob Reimer: 45; 8: Ryan Clifford; 9: Will Watson; 10: Mitch Voit; 11: Jack Wenninger; 12: Elian Peña; 13: Eli Serrano III; 14: Jonathan Santucci; 15: Zach Thornton; 16: Chris Suero; 17: Antonio Jimenez; 18: Dylan Ross; 19: Ryan Lambert; 20: Randy Guzman;

  

Keith Law, The Athletic:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Elian Peña; 6: Mitch Voit; 7: Zach Thornton; 8: Ryan Clifford; 9: Jacob Reimer; 10: Nick Morabito; 11: Jonathan Santucci; 12: Jack Wenninger; 13: Will Watson; 14: Chris Suero; 15: Daiverson Gutierrez; 16: Marco Vargas; 17: Camden Lohman; 18: Boston Baro; 19: Edward Lantigua; 20: Daviel Hurtado;

Ernest Dove:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: Jack Wenninger; 7: Ryan Clifford; 8: Elian Peña; 9: Will Watson; 10: Zach Thornton; 11: Jonathan Santucci; 12: Chris Suero; 13: Yovanny Rodriguez; 14: Mitch Voit; 15: Randy Guzman; 16: Dylan Ross; 17: Ryan Lambert; 18: Brett Banks; 19: Ben Simon; 20: Boston Baro; 21: Eli Serrano III; 22: Trey Snyder; 23: Daviel Hurtado; 24: Jose Chirinos; 25: Edward Lantigua; 26: Daiverson Gutierrez; 27: R.J. Gordon; 28: Yonatan Henriquez; 29: Saul Garcia; 30: Nick Morabito;

 

Mack from Mack’s Mets

1: Jonah Tong; 2: A.J. Ewing; 3: Carson Benge; 4: Elian Peña; 5: Chris Suero; 6: Dylan Ross; 7: Jack Wenninger; 8: Zach Thornton; 9: Will Watson; 10: Ryan Lambert; 11: Jacob Reimer; 12: Yovanny Rodriguez; 13: Wandy Asigen; 14: Noah Hall; 15: Ryan Clifford; 16: Nick Morabito; 17: Jonathan Santucci; 18: R.J. Gordon; 19: Jonathan Pintaro; 20: Saul Garcia; 21: Mitch Voit; 22: Ben Simon; 23: Randy Guzman; 24: Peter Kussow; 25: Hoss Brewer; 26: Daviel Hurtado; 27: Daiverson Gutierrez; 28:Cleiner Ramirez;

 

FanGraphs:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: Jack Wenninger; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: A.J. Ewing; 7: Wandy Asigen; 8: Jonathan Santucci; 9: Will Watson; 10: Ryan Clifford; 11: Elian Peña; 12: Zach Thornton; 13: Chris Suero; 14: R.J. Gordon; 15: Eli Serrano III; 16: Boston Baro; 17:Dylan Ross; 18: Jonathan Pintaro; 19: Nick Morabito; 20: Mitch Voit; 21: Ryan Lambert; 22: Ben Simon; 23: Justin Hagenman; 24: Randy Guzman; 25: Antonio Jimenez; 26: Joel Diaz; 27: Marco Vargas; 28: Yovanny Rodriguez; 29: Yordan Rodriguez; 30: Peter Kussow; 31: Camden Lohman; 32: Jose Chirinos; 33: Heriberto Rincon; 34: Colin Houck; 35: Douglas Orellana; 36: Felipe De La Cruz; 37: Peyton Prescott; 38: Luis Alvarez; 39: Ronald Hernandez; 40: Cleiner Ramirez; 41: Edward Lantigua; 42: Cesar Acosta; 43: Nathan Hall; 44: Calvin Ziegler; 45: Luis R. Rodriguez;

 

Prospects 1500:

1: Carson Benge; 2: Nolan McLean; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: Ryan Clifford; 7: Mitch Voit; 8: Elian Peña; 9: Jonathan Santucci; 10: Jack Wenninger; 11: Nick Morabito; 12: Chris Suero; 13: Will Watson; 14: Eli Serrano III; 15: Boston Baro; 16: Zach Thornton; 17: Marco Vargas; 18: R.J. Gordon; 19: Daiverson Gutierrez; 20: Dylan Ross;  21: Ryan Lambert; 22: Antonio Jimenez; 23: Yovanny Rodriguez; 24: Randy Guzman; 25: Jeremy Rodriguez; 26: Trey Snyder; 27: Peter Kussow; 28: Christian Scott; 29: Edward Lantigua; 30: Colin Houck; 31: Felipe De La Cruz; 32: Camden Lohman; 33: Kevin Parada; 34: Jonathan Pintaro; 35: Ronald Hernandez; 36: Daviel Hurtado; 37: Jose Ramos; 38: Joel Diaz; 39: Cam Tilly; 40: Yonatan Henriquez; 41: Douglas Orellana; 42: Saul Garcia; 43: Julio Zayas; 44: Simon Juan; 45: Yunior Amparo; 46: Joander Suarez; 47: Brendan Girton; 48: Irving Cota; 49: Wyatt Vincent; 50: Jose Chirinos;

 

Metsmerized Online:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: Jonah Tong; 4: A.J. Ewing; 5: Ryan Clifford; 6: Jacob Reimer; 7: Jack Wenninger; 8: Elian Peña; 9: Will Watson; 10: Mitch Voit; 11: Eli Serrano III; 12: Jonathan Santucci; 13: Chris Suero; 14: Wandy Asigen; 15: Nick Morabito; 16: Zach Thornton; 17: Randy Guzman; 18: Ryan Lambert; 19: Boston Baro; 20: Dylan Ross; 21: Antonio Jimenez; 22: Edward Lantigua; 23: R.J. Gordon; 24: Marco Vargas; 25: Daviel Hurtado; 26: Daiverson Gutierrez; 27: Brendan Girton; 28: Peter Kussow; 29: Yovanny Rodriguez; 30: Jonathan Pintaro; 31: Camden Lohman; 32: Jeremy Rodriguez; 33: Felipe De La Cruz; 34: Cam Tilly; 35: Saul Garcia; 36: Ronald Hernandez; 37: Irving Cota; 38: Trey Snyder; 39: Douglas Orellana; 40: D'Andre Smith; 41: Josmir Reyes; 42: Yunior Amparo; 43: Cleiner Ramirez; 44: Nate Lavender; 45: Yordan Rodriguez; 46: Joander Suarez; 47: Ben Simon; 48: Alex Carrillo; 49: Luis Alvarez; 50: Yonatan Henriquez;

 

Joe DiMayo SNY TV:

1: Nolan McLean; 2: Carson Benge; 3: A.J. Ewing; 4: Jonah Tong; 5: Jacob Reimer; 6: Ryan Clifford; 7: Elian Peña; 8: Jack Wenninger; 9: Jonathan Santucci; 10: Mitch Voit; 11: Nick Morabito; 12: Will Watson; 13: Zach Thornton; 14: Chris Suero; 15: Wandy Asigen; 16: Ryan Lambert; 17: Eli Serrano III; 18: Dylan Ross; 19: Randy Guzman; 20: Antonio Jimenez; 21: R.J. Gordon; 22: Jonathan Pintaro; 23: Yovanny Rodriguez; 24: Peter Kussow; 25: Boston Baro; 26: Camden Lohman; 27: Daiverson Gutierrez; 28: Cam Tilly; 29: Nathan Hall; 30: Trey Snyder;